Is a hot dog a sandwich??

[tokeyo]

Well? is it?

[Voss]

this doesn't look like circlejerk. more like serious discussion.

[Stealthbomber16]

this doesn't look like circlejerk. more like serious discussion.

It’s not in either

[tokeyo]

This is as serious as it gets.

[Voss]

I am a dummy. Anyway. To get things back on track..

According to reddit, and the legal definition of a sandwhich:
https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice...of_a_sandwich/

Yes!

[tokeyo]

I am a dummy. Anyway. To get things back on track..

According to reddit, and the legal definition of a sandwhich:
https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice...of_a_sandwich/

Yes!

Reddit is like new-age Wikipedia though, it's hardly the most reliable source of proven fact

For my money, it's NOT

[Cryptonic]

Yes it is. Look up FDA definition of what a sandwich is, hotdog falls in that.

[Apocist]

Yes it is. Look up FDA definition of what a sandwich is, hotdog falls in that.

So a hotdog could be a sandwich in the US, but something else elsewhere.

Gotta love perspective

[Hybrid]

we should exile voss away from this forum because of him murdering this thread's purpose by posting the link of the reddit

[Brendan]

yes

[tokeyo]

When you slap some meat inside two slices of bread, you have a sandwich, at least according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which enforces the safety and labeling of meat and poultry.

"We're talking about a traditional closed-face sandwich," says Mark Wheeler, who works in food safety at the USDA. "A sandwich is a meat or poultry filling between two slices of bread, a bun or a biscuit."

That excludes items like burritos, wraps or hot dogs. For this definition, Wheeler consulted the agency's 202-page Food Standards and Labeling Policy Book.

Taken from this website's article




Sorry friends, a hot dog is not a sandwich. It's a hot dog. Perhaps in its own category of food.. And nothing beats a Costco dog.

[DJarJar]

Taken from this website's article




Sorry friends, a hot dog is not a sandwich. It's a hot dog. Perhaps in its own category of food.. And nothing beats a Costco dog.

By that definition PB&J is not a sandwich (no meat or poultry) and it's probably the most iconic sandwich of all time so that's just stupid.

[Ganelon]

hol up but a is literally a sausage slapped in between two slices of bread, isn't that the definition of a sandwich? or are we talking bread loaves here

[Kenny]

It's not really two seperate slices

[Distorted]

It's not really two seperate slices

This.

It COULD be 2 slices, but I use buns that are 1 piece.

noun
1.
an item of food consisting of two pieces of bread with meat, cheese, or other filling between them, eaten as a light meal.
"a ham sandwich"

I am part of the hotdog is not a sandwich.

#NotMySandwich

[Ganelon]

This.

It COULD be 2 slices, but I use buns that are 1 piece.



I am part of the hotdog is not a sandwich.

#NotMySandwich

okay so it CAN be a sandwich depending on whether or not you use two separate slices?

[Distorted]

okay so it CAN be a sandwich depending on whether or not you use two separate slices?

It can fall into the definition of a sandwich by meeting specific criteria, but just because it falls into the definition it doesnt "become a sandwich".

It's kind of like the same sense of using a truck chassis when making a minivan (which Honda is known for in their odysseys). It falls under the definition of a "truck" but it is not; It is a van. Still though, because of that a lot of computer systems have Honda Odysseys labeled under the truck category.

Hotdog is never a sandwich!

Doubling down on my stance.

[Light_Yagami]

It can fall into the definition of a sandwich by meeting specific criteria, but just because it falls into the definition it doesnt "become a sandwich".

It's kind of like the same sense of using a truck chassis when making a minivan (which Honda is known for in their odysseys). It falls under the definition of a "truck" but it is not; It is a van. Still though, because of that a lot of computer systems have Honda Odysseys labeled under the truck category.

Hotdog is never a sandwich!

Doubling down on my stance.

But What If You Cut 2 Hot Dogs In Half And Put Them On A Hamburger Bun/Two Slices Of Bread? Is It A Sandwich Then?

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Existential questions being asked here. I say, it depends. If you put your dog in the oven (sorry @naz ), then I don't think I would call it a sandwich. On the other hand, putting a wiener in bread is quite similar to standard sandwiches.

Conclusion: it depends on how the Hot Dog is achieved.

[NoctiZ]

I understand this is a heated debate. Can we all agree though on the fact that a hot dog is worse than a cool cat? That is all.

[Ganelon]

Existential questions being asked here. I say, it depends. If you put your dog in the oven (sorry @naz), then I don't think I would call it a sandwich. On the other hand, putting a wiener in bread is quite similar to standard sandwiches.

Conclusion: it depends on how the Hot Dog is achieved.

I understand this is a heated debate. Can we all agree though on the fact that a hot dog is worse than a cool cat? That is all.

I think y'all just insulted half the people on this website.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I understand this is a heated debate. Can we all agree though on the fact that a hot dog is worse than a cool cat? That is all.

I think y'all just insulted half the people on this website.

Yes, and yes.

ALL HAIL THE CAT EMPRESS

[Distorted]

Yes, and yes.

ALL HAIL THE CAT EMPRESS

so...we are supposed to eat cats now?

[Kenny]

so...we are supposed to eat cats now?

They are better than hot dogs

[Marshmallow Marshall]

so...we are supposed to eat cats now?

NEVER.

[AIVION]

I understand this is a heated debate. Can we all agree though on the fact that a hot dog is worse than a cool cat? That is all.

Word ;3

[Distorted]

Just saw this, decided to bring it to its rightful place.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/...wich/75362898/

[Stealthbomber16]

Just saw this, decided to bring it to its rightful place.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/...wich/75362898/

according to an official press release from the National Hot Dog and Sausage Council.

What does it take to earn this power

[Keira]

Well I don't know what's that but I prefer sandwich :3

[Grakylan]

A hot dog is an euphemism for a dick. A sandwich isn't.

[aeramo]

What if you put a hot dog frank in a hot dog bun, then place the entire thing between two slices of bread?

[Marshmallow Marshall]

What if you put a hot dog frank in a hot dog bun, then place the entire thing between two slices of bread?

Then you choke when you try to eat it because there's too much bread ;-;

[Apocist]

Then you choke when you try to eat it because there's too much bread ;-;

Just more mayo to slather on would fix that.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Guys, I'm going to put an end to the discussion, even though the answer goes against all my strongest ideals...

https://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums...73#post1740473

If he said it, it's true and we must all bow before our one true Overlord.