Never Unlucky has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!
Eggy (1 [L-3]): Never Unlucky
Never Unlucky (4 [L-0]): Eggy, AnassRhamur, Minotarr, Mesk514
Chapdat (1 [L-3]): BigBallsMcGG
Never Unlucky has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!
Eggy (1 [L-3]): Never Unlucky
Never Unlucky (4 [L-0]): Eggy, AnassRhamur, Minotarr, Mesk514
Chapdat (1 [L-3]): BigBallsMcGG
Night Two:
After a long day spent hunting for the mafia, the town struggled to succeed, ending up lynching their town leader.
Never Unlucky was lynched. They were a Citizen.
Living Players:
@Minotarr
@BigBallsMcGG
@Mesk514
@Chapdat
@Eggy
@AnassRhamur
Dead Players:
Funce: Lynched Day 1. Sheriff.
Spruance: Killed Night 1. Citizen.
Never Unlucky: Lynched Day 2. Citizen.
Roles List:
Doctor
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Consort
Mafioso
Night ends at this time:
00
00
00
00
DAYS HOURS MINUTES SECONDS
Night Actions must be submitted 1 hour before deadline.
Day Three:
The morning came, and the body of Minotarr was discovered. After gazing upon him, he was easily identified as the Doctor.
Living Players:
@BigBallsMcGG
@Mesk514
@Chapdat
@Eggy
@AnassRhamur
Dead Players:
Funce: Lynched Day 1. Sheriff.
Spruance: Killed Night 1. Citizen.
Never Unlucky: Lynched Day 2. Citizen.
Minotarr: Killed Night 2. Doctor.
Roles List:
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Consort
Mafioso
Day ends at this time:
00
00
00
00
DAYS HOURS MINUTES SECONDS
3 votes to hammer.
Eggy evil confirmed
I'm the backup doctor. i don't have a medical license but i heal with the power of laughter
-vote AnassRhamur
-vote unvote
-vote Chapdat
-vote Chapdatgood game lol
Chapdat has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!
Chapdat (3 [L-0]): AnassRhamur, Mesk514, Eggy
Chapdat was lynched. He was a Citizen.
Congratulations to Mesk514 (Mafioso) and Eggy (Consort) for winning
P.S sorry this is so late but I've been busy so haven't really had time to do it today.
99 votes to hammer.
I have no idea what happened to that last day. >....>
Maybe host would like to give some thoughts too? I lack information on who was whose mentor.
Like did people just give up? Don't give up guys, you can't win that way.
#neversurrender
in my opinion there was a huge lack of persuasion on towns part. + the AFK. I mean, Funce only had to post that he was Sheriff and he wouldn't have been lynched and Day 2 Eggy was at L-1, but no one could throughly explain why he was scum and took it as a joke.
Mirrored some of my thoughts too. There is a world where I could see a sheriff being lynched day 1, but it usually requires a counterclaim. Same with Eggy, though that one was a bit more forgivable.
Town definitely should have been more cautious at Lynch or Lose.
Not that I'm anywhere near qualified to be a mentor, but for future reference did the mentors explain things well enough?
I know this was a Beginner's Game, but I would have liked to see some VCA (Vote Count Analysis), especially toward the end. The Town had the benefit of witnessing multiple mislynches, but never really thought about why players were voting the way they were, even toward the end of the game. Pretty sure that Mesk and Eggy were on most of the mislynches which occurred this game -- that should have been a decent clue at least one of them was scum (if not both, which was the case). Not saying that Town players aren't sometimes mislynching a lot by accident, but one's voting record is at least an objective means of trying to determine alignment.
My impression was that the players in this game just didn't get into it for whatever reason. The activity levels just weren't high (19 pages for a full game is super low) and sustaining enough that momentum ever really picked up. That type of thing usually benefits the scum, since they can just wait the clock out and can lurk themselves. The Sheriff being lynched on d1 while AFK killed off a ton of confidence for the Town, and I think without a Sheriff, the players weren't able to step it up in a purely scumreading type of a game, which is the tough adjustment over to Forum Mafia from the mod or elsewhere.
Last edited by DarknessB; August 9th, 2016 at 10:27 AM.
The majority of the players did not have a mentor by request, but Dragon had one, as well as Funce and Never Unlucky. The rest of the players didn't have one.
I believe it is partially my fault that the game did not go perfectly as I ended up being busier towards the end. As much as I could, the early drop out and the amount of people not active made it difficult to keep everyone active. It was a bit disappointing though because I had talked with everyone before and during the game to try to prompt players to actually play, I don't know for sure if it was just everyone was on at the wrong time or if they were busy or lost interest.
MaftZed was mentoring Dragon before he left
Funce was mentored by TDL until they were lynched
Never Unlucky was with Calix
The host told me he was going to cancel the game day 2; I stopped posting with that in mind. I'd have gotten you lynched otherwise.
Calix didn't play the game for me. No, she didn't "lead" me to victory.
Town idiot who figured out the scum :') Eggy, trust me when I say this, you're horrendous at this game. I've scum-read you in the 3 games you were scum. Step up your game, pleb.
And how many of those games did I lose? One game I replaced at the end?? dont be mad kid. If u kno im scum its your job to get me lynched. You cant lead a lynch for your life lol. You would have done better this game if you were afk. You claiming tht I was scum and pussying out instead of supplying a case made you such an easy lynch lol.
Ok
Just to let u guys know
i luvvv oranges
and all that
:P