Green - Very likely town
Dark Green - Decent chance they're town
Yellow - Undecided
Orange - Scummy
Red - Very Scummy (mafia, sk, student or benign neut)
Goremancer - Ubernox saw him visiting LeaD who was apparently recruited twice (once by me). If mason leader (get him to claim) Goremancer is probably town or the student since he didn't use his seek mafia ability (Ubernox would have seen him visiting 2 people if he did) unless pebrock forgot which is also possible. Not claiming and not confirming Ubernox was unhelpful. pebrock was kind of scummy on day 1. Chance of scum but need him to talk more.
Fatalis - Using doctor instead of detective was dumb as the detective is very useful in this setup due to the mafia seek ability. Claims to have Vigilante / Mafioso which is a bit odd when Chill Kidd is also forced to shoot but he is convincing that he has those abilities. Good that he threatened lurkers with his shot. Even with the weird night 1 choice I'm leaning towards town.
Bahkieh - Blackmailer. If he's not the blackmailer then both Chill (swapped with me) and Bahkieh were framed and Bluejay lied. Voted Auckmid which shows scum might be ok with voting a possible gf or sk from Jr's LW (see Capitalier). If town derpiness means he didn't get shot you'll have to lynch him (at the end of the day) or shoot him the next night.
ReauxTzunami - Still doesn't seem to understand how the role he supposedly used works. Thinks he should be checking people who he thinks will die with the sleuth. His day 1 post about risking killing off a teammate, mafia being separated and "one wrong move and the first few days could fall apart" seemed like it should be in mafia chat not day chat as it applied much more to them than town. Sleuths Cryptonic for bad reasons and says no lw (cits more likely than most not to leave one) + could have got lucky when LeaD (his actual target) said he didn't leave one. Not many people leave lws n1 so sleuth is an easy claim. 2 sleuths on n1 unlikely when last wills are rare.
Ubernox - Probably used detective ability (not confirmed but his claim seemed genuine). Could have done it to get town cred or to find fellow mafia though. Defends Auckmid. Helps town a lot. Knows how riddle worked but keeps double vote secret? Upfront about not thinking they should claim though.
Kromos - Town Power
Bluejay - Kind of scummy in day 1 + blackmailed doesn't mean much with no night chats. If he doesn't give his abilities from night 1 and 2 + give his thoughts on day 2 in my interview he is likely to be scum. If Bahkieh flips town he lied about being blackmailed and should be shot at night. Shooting a ghost isn't a big deal.
Capitalier - Voted with me when I suggested using option C to confirm whether he visited me. I was framed last night (swapped onto Chill) so he could be that framer. Instantly "believed" Jr's last will and used it to train Auckmid even though mafia last wills are almost always lies. His claim to have watched pebrock could have come from the accusations pebrocks was receiving on day 2 not from his few day 1 posts. I wasn't as active on day 1 as I was on day 2 so his reasoning for guarding me could also have come from day 2 instead of day 1. 2 targets would explain frame (me) + mafia seek (pebrock) if he were followed. Active lurking.
Cryptonic - Uncced cit.
Brendan - Uncced town KPN.
ajkei - Seems to be confirmed that he used the sleuth (or dirty sleuth) ability. Likely owner of a double vote after saying the answer in day chat but decides to keep this a secret on day 2? Defends Auckmid. Leaning towards town but not strongly.
Auckmid - Could easily be GF or SK as mafia's night 1 attack is still unaccounted for or even scum who wasn't attacked. Armoursmith claim can be "confirmed" by his student claiming or he hopes to find a mafia member to claim vested which would explain why he didn't want to tell us who he gave the armour to yesterday. He should know the risks of giving armour to scum after FM 12 where he and many other scum got armour, yet he still decided to risk it. If he gave it to anyone other than Cryptonic I find it highly unlikely he gave armour at all. In defence says he's not evil neut (leaves out gf) then switches to saying maf wouldn't pressure a teammate (their gf). Possible slip. Uses meta and caps in defence = common scum defence + says he won't claim even though him claiming armoursmith shouldn't have been a problem at all. Makes it sound as if he won't claim his role which as a town power I don't think about. Says he will "prove that I am not the neutral killer" from feedback but he can't because the student can make that feedback and they might have made a code telling each other roles + he doesn't say he can prove that he's not mafia. Force him to claim who he gave armour to tomorrow.
Chill Kidd - Uncced cit, confirmed BD/kidnapper. I was swapped with him which means he was probably framed instead of me to appear to have visited Bluejay.
Nick - "BRAINSS" in cyan, "-skip day", and "Benign Neutrals are fun fun fun. Not Ghost though." from day 1 hints at benign neut. He mentions benign neuts more than anyone on day 2. Unconvincing doc claim + no second ability. If he was telling the truth about visiting me he could be the framer + he mentions this "I think even getting getting a framed person is fine. Cause now we know whom visited whom." Generally helpful day chat.
FrostByte - Lurker. Good chance he's scum but I don't have much posts to read.
LeaD - Kind of lurky but says rl reasons. Another doc claim but at least his second role explains it. Didn't claim double recruited until asked which I found a bit weird. More likely town than not but need to see some more posts.
Rocshi - Uncced cit (troll claim?). Near useless in day chat and refuses to claim his ability. Could be a jester/ghost and the real cit hasn't claimed. The real cit must cc him tomorrow if there is one.
CmG - Trying unusually hard to look pro-town, especially on day 1? Doesn't claim because "it will make sense sooner or later". It probably won't be justified. Helpful day chat. Leaning towards town.
Glip - I'm guessing scum/neutral of some sort. He didn't claim his abilities as soon as he could before he was burned and cleaned which any town should have done.
Jr4life24 - Doesn't make much sense for a mafia to give the town their gf or sk in their lw but the mafia KPN is unaccounted for otherwise so idk. The problem the mafia have with no night chat is that all of them might choose not to kill thinking that another member will which could also explain the no kill.